Monday, November 15, 2010

Marzano Ch 9

Summary:
This chapter of Classroom Instruction explores the research and usage of generating and testing hypotheses in a classroom setting. Marzano asserts that also we engage in hypothesis generation almost automatically, there are steps that can be taken to mold it into a teaching tool. He argues that teachers should be open to students who wish to either inductively and or deductively approach the process of hypothesis generation. He then claims that teachers must encourage students to be very clear and specific about the student’s hypothesis and conclusions. Although hypothesis usage is commonly thought of as a science specific task, Marzano asserts that any subject can make adequate use of the procedure by giving the following examples; systems analysis, problem solving, historical investigation, invention, experimental inquiry and decision making. All of these strategies have multi-curriculum uses and can be implemented with ease to do the fact that our thinking processes are set up to do these naturally.

Connection:
The connection I made with this chapter of Classroom Instruction is with chapter 4 of The Art and Science of Teaching. Both of these chapters focus on how teachers are best able to assist students in the generation and testing of hypotheses. The first similarity is to encourage students to make sure they are backing up their ideas with observable evidence. What we know is only one side to the importance of knowledge. If we are to defend our positions we must know why and how we know it as well. Marzano continues his thoughts of hypothesis generation and testing by asserting that using hypotheses helps to encourage students to think on a higher level. The student must not only come to a conclusion, but also be able to take that conclusion and apply or create something new and useable.

Application:
In my Civics 12 class I use an unnamed system of hypothesis generation and testing. When I ask students to reflect on what they know and ask them to assert what they believe was the cause of an issue or how that issue will affect future generations they are using the skills associated with hypothesis generation and testing without knowing it. I do agree with Marzano that using hypothesis is a general way in which many people learn that occurs naturally and not also in the scientific method fashion that we were taught in science classes. A specific way in which I recently used the principles of hypothesis generation in my class was to show students the need for financial planning by having them construct a working budget. Once the budgets were finished I presented them with emergency situation that had to be accounted for i.e. hospital visits, car accidents etc. Each student now had to solve the problem of how much will these things will cost and how they must change or alter their budget to be able to cover these expenses and how these unexpected costs will affect them for the long term.

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Marzano Ch 10

Summary:
This section of Classroom Instruction speaks about how important it is for students to activate their prior knowledge. The chapter begins with an experiment that shows how prior knowledge can influence our perceptions. The first strategy in the chapter is the use of cues and questions. When using these techniques it is important to focus on the key issues of the lesson, rely on questions that encourage students to higher levels of thinking, give students enough time to fully develop their answers and can be used before the lesson to guide learning. The two main types of cue and question usage in a classroom are explicit cues that allow students create inferences to bridge the gap between what they know and do not know and analytical questions that allow students to think about the questions themselves to gain a deeper understanding. The chapter concludes with the ideas pertaining to advance organizers. When using advance organizers it is important to focus on critical information, encourage higher level thinking, use even when information is difficult to organize and allow for different organizers for different results.

Connections:
The main connection I made from this chapter of Classroom Instruction is in chapter 2 of The Art and Science of Teaching. This chapter dealt with the strategies involved with helping students explore new material. The strategies discussed in this chapter of Classroom Instruction provide a meaningful way to help students create understanding from what they already know. Cues and questions allow students to dig deeper into their prior knowledge to create similarities and differences with the topics they are currently learning. When students already back a foundation of personal knowledge it is much easier for them to build the new ideas into their preexisting understanding.

Application:
In my clinical I try to use questioning whenever the situation will allow. In a civics classroom it is important to remind students that the material they are learning about it pointless unless they can connect it to their everyday lives and gain a new understanding of the world from it. I encourage them to consider how of current system enhances and hinders their lives and freedoms and what alternatives could we propose to make the system more beneficial to all or to them individually. I am always surprised at how much they are aware and know and it only makes my task easier when they can relate a topic to something they already have learned. I do plan on using advance organizers more often. I am an auditory learning and I must make myself get into the habit of using visual learning tools more often in class. This is especially useful in civics because many of the ideas in class are quite hard to categorize in one criteria and can often be a part of many different topics.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Marzano Ch 7

Summary:
This chapter of Classroom Instruction explores the research and practice behind using cooperative learning effectively in the classroom. The distinction between grouping in a general sense and cooperative learning is that grouping is generally done by the school to select the class size and make-up but cooperative learning is under the teacher’s control within the classroom. The core principles or cooperative learning account for mutual dependence, helping their peers, contributing to a common goal, building social skills and reflecting on the dynamics of the group. The authors assert that for cooperative learning to be effective the teacher must create the groups heterogeneously instead of by talent or ability, keep the groups small and use it for a purpose and regularly but not overbearingly.

Connection:
The main connection with this chapter of Classroom Instruction is in chapter three of The Art and Science of Teaching that speaks about deepening understanding of knowledge. Although that chapter does not speak directly about cooperative learning, I that that cooperative learning could easily be incorporated into the meaning of the chapter. Marzano asserts that students gain knowledge not only from the teacher but also from their peers and their parents. Since students will gain understanding from their peers it would make sense from this to be used and shaped by the teacher so that the learning taking place is accurate and beneficial. Whether used to help practice skills or to understand a new section of material that use of cooperative learning is an engaging and fun way for students to learn and grow socially.

Application:
In my classroom I have tried to focus heavily on the use of cooperative learning. I am under the belief that when you pair peer teaching with guidance from the teacher you give students the best chance to succeed. Also the added benefit of improved social skills is a much more practical and important skill that every student will use for the remainder of their lives. An activity we did in class was a mock session of congress. In the lesson each group was assigned to either the Senate or the House and was further divided into a committee and subcommittee. Each different group had to compromise with each other in order to give the bill a chance to go through each house of Congress and ultimately sent to the acting president. Through this lesson each student became familiar with the process of passing a bill into law and why it can be such a long and difficult process. The students were also using the lesson to improve their social skills and their ability to compromise to achieve a common goal.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Marzano Ch 4

Summary:
This chapter of Classroom Instruction speaks about the research surrounding how effort and recognition effect performance in the classroom. The chapter begins by examining the four most frequent concepts attributed to success. The problematic ideas students believe helps to attribute to their success is ability, other people and luck. Each of these things can be positive under the right circumstances but when the situation is reversed they can negatively affect performance. The most beneficial belief that students can have is in their level of effort. This is important to note because many students do not realize the significance of believing in their effort but can be taught to remodel their ideas to reinforce their belief in effort. The author asserts that the best way to increase students focus on effort is to explicitly state examples of when effort has paid off for others and allow students the means to record their effort level. The second half of the chapter switches focus toward the ideas and research behind providing recognition to students. The authors asserts that recognition is different from the ideas of praise or reward. Rewards can be viewed as having a negative effect on motivation and are generally most effective when they are linked to a standard of performance. The best use recognition occurs when it is used in an abstract symbolic manner.
Connections:
The main connection with chapter 4 of Classroom Instruction goes back to chapter 1 of The Art and Science of Teaching. These chapters both focus heavily on the differences between praise, reward and recognition. Both texts come to the assertion that for reward to be best used it must be varied and can bridge between verbal and physical symbolic means. Regardless of the appropriate form of recognition the general consensus in the research is that it has positive effect on student performance. This is a very basic but often misunderstood means of providing students with the best chance to succeed in the classroom.
Application:
After reading though this chapter I though back to my first week of clinical and found that my assigned teacher was very deliberate and well versed in providing abstract recognition. He did not partake in any physical reward system but he did use verbal recognition in a very useful manner. He made it a point to recognize a student that had made a particular clever or insightful comment and made sure the class as a whole had heard to idea. I tried to gauge the expression of the student who made the comment during this class and she seemed to have been very proud that her idea was taken so highly. This is an excellent real life example of the usage of proper and beneficial recognition from a teacher to student.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Marzano Ch 5

Summary
This chapter focuses on the usefulness of homework and practice in the educational system. Marzano asserts that homework is more effective and should be used more frequently the older the student is. Another key strategy is to keep parents’ involvement as low as possible. This is because of the parents’ tendency to solve the problem for their children. Thirdly, homework’s purpose should be clearly defined as to whether it is to be for practice or to introduce a new concept. Lastly, homework that is assigned should always be used to give feedback to students. Marzano continues his discussion of homework by arguing that it should be established through a policy, clearly defined and the feedback from home work should be varied. Marzano continues the chapter by exploring the research behind practice. For practice to be effective it must be focused, given adequate time and should allow for students to personalize their approach.
Connections
The connection I made with chapter five of Classroom Instruction are with the concepts of procedural and declarative knowledge in chapter three of The Art and Science of Teaching. Marzano reinforces the research behind homework and practice in both texts and continues the assertion that homework is best suited toward secondary education rather than primary education. Marzano also argues that practice is best suited for procedural learning because of its repetitive and hands on nature. When homework is observed it appears to be well suited to either procedural or declarative knowledge. Marzano also warns the danger of parental involvement in homework in both texts. He asserts that both parents and students should be aware of the reason and purpose for the homework and those parents should set up a system for their children to do the work but should not actively participate in the activity. Marzano adds in The Art and Science of Teaching that homework should also be designed for high completion rates so that it better reinforces the student’s familiarity with the topic.
Application
Since my decision to become a teacher I have had many opportunities to consider what I want my classroom to be like and how I would wish for it to be structured. Homework is one strategy that I would like to hold to the minimum. This would of course be dependent on the age of the students. With all the responsibilities and need for extracurricular activities and social growth I feel that homework can sometimes be detrimental to a student’s overall development. If a student has seven classes and each class assigns homework for the evening then the student has little to no ability explore their personal interests or develop social connections with their peers. Assuming students spend eight hours in school and eight hours sleeping it does not make sense to bombard them with four or five hours of homework a night. This being said I do believe homework has its place but must be used at an appropriate rate and length and only when truly needed.

Monday, September 27, 2010

Marzano Ch 6

Summary:
The focus of chapter six of Classroom Instruction that Works revolves on nonlinguistic representations of knowledge. This notion is centered by the psychological view of dual coding. In this view knowledge is stored both linguistically and in the form of images. Marzano begins the chapter with an overview of the most common types of nonlinguistic representations. These include graphic representations, physical models, mental pictures, pictographs and kinesthetic activities. The purpose of using nonlinguistic representations, according to Marzano, is so that the student has the chance to elaborate his or her knowledge, thus making it more easy to recall as well as being better understood.

Connection:
The main connection with this chapter of Classroom Instruction is with chapter five of Art and Science of Teaching entitled "What will I do to engage students?" As a prospective teacher I believe that it is important to gain the interest of your students in the lesson rather than simply force knowledge upon them. Using nonlinguistic representations is a effective way to build engagement. When a student has the ability to make an idea physical they connect it with the real world. This helps the student see the reason for learning the material as well as to understand it more fully. Another benefit comes from the increased motivation to learn that an engaged student has. When a student has a person interest in the lesson they will be more motivated to learn and thus will probably have a more firm grasp of the material.

Application:
Nonlinguistic representations have a broad and effective use in the social studies classroom. It is very difficult for students to connect with the knowledge and have a mastery of the lesson if the teacher does not make any effort in presenting the knowledge in a nonlinguistic way. It is one thing to hear someone speak about a historical event but it is something else entirely to see a photograph from the period of witness a historical reenactment. I believe that when you only expose a student to the linguistic element of knowledge you are only giving him or her half the experience. When you are able to bridge the gap between the spoken knowledge and its visual representation you have given the student a much better and deep understanding.

Monday, September 20, 2010

Marzano Ch 3

Summary:
The focus of this chapter of Classroom Instruction centers on the task of summarizing and note taking. The authors assert that these two skills can be combined because both their goal is to break down information and synthesize it. To be effective at summarization the text asserts that students must know when and how to delete, substitute and keep certain pieces of information. To be adept at these tasks students must be able analyze the information at an advanced level and be aware of the explicit nature of most texts. The chapter continues with several examples of summarization techniques. Among these techniques are the narrative, topic-restriction-illustration, definition, argumentation, problem/solution and conversation frames. The author concludes the chapter with a focus on note taking. They assert that verbatim note taking is the least beneficial form of note taking. Notes should be viewed as a work in progress that will help in studying of tests and the student should create as many notes as possible. The author continues to overview types of note taking that include alpha-numeric outlines, informal outlines and webbings.

Connections:
The connection I made with this section of Classroom Instruction pertains to the chapter in the Art and Science of Teaching titled "What Will I do to Help Students Effectively Interact with New Knowledge?" The skills of summarizing and note taking are an excellent way for students to create a sense of understanding with a new set of information. These skills allow students to personalize and customize their means of understanding. Since each student will bring a specific and personal means of learning, teachers must be aware that each student will also have his or her preference in summarization and note taking. When the student has been introduced to a system that is best suited to his or her needs, their comprehension of new material should be more in depth and more easily understood.

Application:
I took this chapter as especially important as a prospective social studies teacher. Unlike a subject such as math that can be logically understood, most social studies information requires in depth reading and perspective. If a student is aware that the square root of 9 is 3 and the square root of 16 is 4, then they should logically be able to determine that the square root of 25 is 5. However, in a social studies classroom, the way we transfer information to students has to be done with summarizing and good note taking. It is impossible to cover all the historical aspects of an event or time in the modern classroom. Because of this issue the teacher must summarize his lesson to fit the most critical information and students must further summarize the lesson in order to develop a person and working knowledge of the event.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Marzano Ch 2

Summary:

This chapter of Classroom Instruction explores the strategy of using similarities and differences in the classroom as a learning technique. The chapter begins with the story of two problems. The first problem deals with a medical and scientific dilemma. The majority of people faced with this problem would be unable to find the correct answer. However, after reading the second problem which tells of a dictator to be deposed the students are then able to go back and solve the first problem. Although these two issues have very little in common the ideas needed to solve the problem were similar. Marzano asserts that the best practices for using similarities and differences in the classroom are to be explicit in meaning, allowing students to form their own ideas of similarities and differences, portraying similarities and differences in visual form and using varied methods to convey these ideas. Marzano concludes the chapter by over viewing four key techniques of similarities and differences. These techniques are comparison, classifying, metaphor and analogies.

Connections:

The main connection with this chapter of Classroom Instruction is in chapter three of The Art and Science of Teaching. Both texts assert the usefulness of using comparison, classifying, metaphor and analogies in instructional practices. The latter text goes into more specific detail and asserts that the use of identifying similarities and differences is best suited for declarative knowledge rather than procedural knowledge. This is due to the fact that similarities and differences is an idea that ranges over a broad variety of people and can help to create understanding of a once unfamiliar topic by examining it next to something else. This is different than procedural knowledge in that, according to Marzano, it is best explored through practice.

Application:

This chapter of Marzano is not a new concept to me but it does help to legitimize the ideas of similarity and difference in the classroom. Without having read this chapter these strategies would have been something I would have used in my class but definitely not in the more beneficial or direct manner. One specific application I can think of for using similarities and differences in the classroom for social studies is the comparison of early civilizations. It is important to understand what certain civilizations have in common and how they are different and how these aspects created the process of how they understood their world. Another idea I will take from this chapter is the idea to often attempt to represent these strategies visually, such as in a Venn diagram and a chart that the students can interpret their own meaning from.

Monday, August 30, 2010

Marzano Ch 8

Summary:
            This chapter of Classroom Instruction focuses on what procedures and strategies are most effective in setting objectives in the classroom and how best to provide students with feedback.  Marzano begins the chapter with the assertion that instructional goals must be carefully planned in order to be best suited to your students.  The first advice on instructional goals, according to Marzano, is to create goals that are not too specific. Goals that are too specific can narrow a student's focus and cause the students to ignore relevant information that may have been left outside of the narrow goal. Marzano also advises to make sure goals are flexible and are up to personalization by the individual student. Marzano continues the chapter by addressing the topic of corrective feedback.  Marzano asserts that it is the teachers duty to explain what is specifically correct and incorrect about the results of an exam or other assessment tool without much of a time delay between the feedback and the assessment. The last thought Marzano presents is the possibility of student lead feedback.  Marzano asserts that some students are more than capable to providing self or peer feedback and if applicable this can be of great effectiveness in the classroom.
Connections to other Texts:
            The connection with Chapter 8 of Classroom Instruction that I chose to focus on is located in Chapter 1 of The Art and Science of Teaching.  The ideas of instructional goals of Classroom Instruction are looked at more specifically in The Art and Science of Teaching.  In the latter text Marzano breaks the goal setting process down into two distinct forms. These forms are declarative and procedural knowledge.  A declarative goal is the assumption that students will understand a topic and a procedure goal is the idea that students will be able to do a specific task.  These ideas flow well with Marzano's advice in Classroom Instruction to create instructional goals that are not too specific.  Where Classroom Instruction works well to give teachers an idea of the theory behind goal settings, The Art of Science and Teaching appears to be aimed as a much more detail specific guide to effective teaching.   
Application to my Teaching Interest:
            As a teacher in training I feel that it is important to compare the ideas presented in the text with what I had previously thought about goal settings.  Although, I am much more familiar with the specifics of goal setting after reading the two Marzano texts, I did feel relieved to realize that my general ideas of goal setting aligned with the assertions Marzano makes. Another thought that strikes my specific thoughts as a prospective teacher is the idea of student involvement in goals and feedback.  I believe that it is important to give students some amount of ownership over their tasks and lessons.  I think that when students feel that they have some autonomy in the classroom they are more able to become interested and motivated than if they felt they had no ability to have input.