Summary:
This chapter of Classroom Instruction explores the strategy of using similarities and differences in the classroom as a learning technique. The chapter begins with the story of two problems. The first problem deals with a medical and scientific dilemma. The majority of people faced with this problem would be unable to find the correct answer. However, after reading the second problem which tells of a dictator to be deposed the students are then able to go back and solve the first problem. Although these two issues have very little in common the ideas needed to solve the problem were similar. Marzano asserts that the best practices for using similarities and differences in the classroom are to be explicit in meaning, allowing students to form their own ideas of similarities and differences, portraying similarities and differences in visual form and using varied methods to convey these ideas. Marzano concludes the chapter by over viewing four key techniques of similarities and differences. These techniques are comparison, classifying, metaphor and analogies.
Connections:
The main connection with this chapter of Classroom Instruction is in chapter three of The Art and Science of Teaching. Both texts assert the usefulness of using comparison, classifying, metaphor and analogies in instructional practices. The latter text goes into more specific detail and asserts that the use of identifying similarities and differences is best suited for declarative knowledge rather than procedural knowledge. This is due to the fact that similarities and differences is an idea that ranges over a broad variety of people and can help to create understanding of a once unfamiliar topic by examining it next to something else. This is different than procedural knowledge in that, according to Marzano, it is best explored through practice.
Application:
This chapter of Marzano is not a new concept to me but it does help to legitimize the ideas of similarity and difference in the classroom. Without having read this chapter these strategies would have been something I would have used in my class but definitely not in the more beneficial or direct manner. One specific application I can think of for using similarities and differences in the classroom for social studies is the comparison of early civilizations. It is important to understand what certain civilizations have in common and how they are different and how these aspects created the process of how they understood their world. Another idea I will take from this chapter is the idea to often attempt to represent these strategies visually, such as in a Venn diagram and a chart that the students can interpret their own meaning from.
Venn Diagrams are always fun. Although sometimes I did not like doing them in some of my classes, they do benefit the student to help visually organize the information being presented. Which is very important in a social studies classroom.
ReplyDeleteThanks Todd for the comment! I agree that while venn diagrams may not be every student's favorite assignment, they are helpful in visually organizing important information.
ReplyDeleteDr. C.
A visual aid to study by is a very good point. Some times students get that visual picture when trying to remember something. Venn diagrams are very good for the social studies class, very good point.
ReplyDelete